Anna Porter Artist - Fine Art

Blog

How to import photos from a Canon DSLR camera to Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite

How to import photos from a Canon DSLR camera to Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite
How to import photos from a Canon DSLR camera to Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite

I spent all of my beautiful Saturday afternoon trying to find a way to import photos from my Canon camera to my iMac mid-2011 that I recently upgraded to Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite, only to find out that, according to Apple Support Chat, Canon no longer provides driver or software support for photo transfer from Canon cameras to Apple iMacs running Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite. I was told by Apple verbatim, "This is a Canon problem and you will just have to wait until Canon comes out with drivers and photo transfer software that works with Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite." Even though prior to Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite, every other operating system that Apple has produced since I bought my first iMac computer in 2007 and all Apple photo editing software (iPhoto, Image Capture, Aperture), plus Adobe Lightroom 5, imported photos just fine from my Canon camera.

 

Now, as a part-time professional photographer and fine artist, I know there are a lot of professional photographers and fine artists out there who own Macs and Canon cameras. A whole lot. And for Apple's position to be "Hey, this is a Canon problem and you will just have to put your business and livelihood on hold until Canon fixes it. It's not Apple's problem." is well, a little callous to say the least. If not downright UNsupportive and certainly not what I paid for when I purchased my AppleCare support agreement that does not expire until December 20, 2014. My response to the end of that Apple Support Chat was "You know I used to be able to upgrade my iMac to the latest Mac OS X release and not have to worry about compatibility issues. It just worked. Now it just doesn't." To which the Apple Support Chat response was "Have a nice day". I am not kidding.

 

Fortunately though, Canon technical support provided a workaround that Apple should also be aware of, but apparently isn't. Or else, if it is, it is not sharing that information with its customers who have active AppleCare Support agreements, which I do have. Apparently even the oldest Canon DSLR camera, which I happen to own, a Canon EOS Digital Rebel (the original), supports the Picture Transfer Protocol driver which is built into all Macs, even the ones running Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite. Canon technical support told me that all I needed to do was make a simple change on the camera settings. Change the Communication method from "Normal" to "PTP". That's it. When I did that, Apple's Image Capture software was then able to see and transfer my photos. Although it still would not display the thumbnail previews for images captured in RAW format on my camera with the PTP communications setting, it did transfer those images in RAW format correctly to my iMac hard drive where I could then view them in Finder and Preview, and more importantly import them to iPhoto, Aperture or Lightroom 5 for editing.

 

I am posting this in the hopes that someone else who is experiencing this problem will not have to spend an entire sunny Saturday afternoon in early November (a rare occurrence in the Pacific Northwest) trying in vain to upload photos from their Canon camera that are critical for their business to their Apple iMac running Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite, which is also critical for their business, only to have Apple Chat Support tell them that they just have to wait until Canon fixes it and "it's not Apple's problem", when every Mac has a built-in driver that is compatible with all Canon DSLR cameras. Too bad Apple does not share this information with their Support personnel and their iMac customers who have active AppleCare Support agreements that they purchased less than 2 years ago. Fortunately Canon does. Even for their customers who bought an original Canon EOS Digital Rebel DSLR camera 8 years ago and who have no support agreement.

Topics: Art Marketing | Marketing 101 | Marketing Consulting | Marketing for Artists | Marketing for Creatives | Marketing for Photographers | Online Marketing | Social Network Marketing | Struggle as an Artist 

Comments

57 Responses to How to import photos from a Canon DSLR camera to Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite

Thank you so much. You saved me a lot of time and frustration!

To Barbara:

You are most welcome. I am really glad it helped. :)

Thank You! Solved my problem with Yosemite and Canon 30D. However, in 30D it was under "Print order/Set up/" and "Print type = Index". There was no "Communications" settings but your article gave me some direction to go.

To Esko:

Glad it was helpful. Thanks for providing the additional information for the Canon 30D.

Thank you so very much for this article and valuable information. I have a DSLR, Canon Rebel t3 without a tiltable view finder and I am a YouTuber which I would like to use to take my videos and then upload to my MAC OS X 10.10 Yosemite and edit through iMovie. ?s ... when taking pictures (as you talked about) or taking videos (as I will mostly be doing) do you have the Communication method set on Normal for this process and then change it to PTP only when you are transferring to the Mac? Also, do you know if this communication setting is set to PTP will I be able to hook the camera up to my Mac while recording and use my Mac as my monitor? Any help is GREATLY appreciated. I am a novice at this and haven't used this camera much (been stored in original packaging) until now.

Thank god i found your side, but how about canon 5d mark 3hop you can help me.

In reply to Jens: You should be able to find Yosemite drivers for a Canon 5D Mark III on the Canon support website. It is a much newer camera than my original 2006 Canon EOS Digital Rebel.

Anna Porter

Does anyone know if the option to change the Communication setting to PTP is available on the Canon Rebel T3i? I am struggling to import my photos to my Mac and it's driving me crazy!

In response to Vesna -

My understanding from the email that I received from Canon on this when Apple first came out with Yosemite, is that transferring the photos via PTP works to transfer photos from all Canon cameras to Mac OS X Yosemite. You may not need to do this; however, IF Canon and/or Apple now has a driver for Yosemite for your model camera. I would check on the Canon website first (http://CanonUSA.com) under Support - Software and Drivers. If there is no driver for Yosemite for your model camera, and you cannot transfer the photos then try changing the Communications setting on the camera to PTP.

To do this, go to the menu on the camera, find Communications and change it to PTP. Exit out of the menu after making the change. With your camera turned on, connect the camera to your Mac. Open Image Capture on your Mac and select the camera (it should appear under Devices). Once the photos have loaded in Image Capture, go the toolbar on bottom of the screen and select a folder where you want Image Capture to store the photos. Then select Import All Photos (or Import Selected Photos) to transfer the photos from the camera to your Mac. From there you can simply drag the whole folder or individual photos into whatever application you are using for photo editing/photo library management, e.g. Photos, Aperture, Lightroom etc.

You can also buy an inexpensive USB Card Reader that will read SDHC, Micro SD and Compact Flash cards, and use the Card Reader to transfer the images from the camera's storage media to your Mac, instead of connecting the camera directly to your Mac. This might be a faster method of transferring photos, depending on the processor speed on your camera. For me, it is a lot faster to transfer photos from my Canon's Compact Flash card via a Card Reader than it is to connect my Canon EOS Digital Rebel to my Mac and transfer them directly from the camera.

Thank you, Anna for taking the time to reply to my question. I did, in fact, purchase a card reader based on your suggestion and had no further difficulties importing my pictures. Many thanks!

In response to Vesna: You are most welcome, Vesna. Glad to be of help.

Thank you!!!! I was wondering why I could do this with my old mac but not with the one I recently purchased. Very helpful!

In response to Carolina:

You are most welcome Carolina. I am glad it helped!

Anna

Yes, indeed, thanks. I am new to digital photography but increasing in skill and interest, working with a Kodak 14-mp and Kodak EasyShare software and recently upgraded to El Capitan 10.11.3 which required me to basically degrade the Kodak Software for which there is now no support by either Kodak or Apple. I think it's because Apple wants us to buy an iPhone or an iPad. I would look into a small digital but would probably rather go up to a $600-+or- Canon, but wonder if Apple will support the software necessary. And just when I started to get good and start printing metal prints...

In response to Msgr. Jouet:

I am not familiar with Kodak equipment or software, so I cannot speak to that. If your camera has the ability to change the communications setting on it to PTP, then my suggestions above should, in theory, also work with your existing equipment. And the card reader workaround should also work. A $20.00 card reader costs a lot less than a new camera.

However, I can address your second concern. Recently I purchased a new Canon EOS Rebel SL1 camera and lenses. I loaded all Canon software that came with the purchase and made sure everything was up-to-date. I was able to connect the new camera directly to my iMac mid-2011 running Mac OS X El Capitan 10.11.3, and both Photos and Image Capture were able to accept photos directly from the camera, without my changing the default communications settings on the camera.

If you do, indeed, purchase a new camera (regardless of manufacturer), be sure to get a recent model (the definition of recent will vary by manufacturer), so that you are certain that the manufacturer has the required drivers to support the operating system on your Mac. A visit to the Drivers and Downloads section on the manufacturer's website should provide you with the information you need to make a decision. Failing that, an email to their Customer Support (or if in the pre-purchase phase, their Sales Support) should get you the information you need.

Hope this helps.

Anna

Thanks, immensely, Anna. I have in mind the same Canon and your understanding parallels mine, which is great because you're the pro. And I think I will pay a visit to an Apple Store or spend a lot of time online at the "App" store to figure how what photography software I should have. I've been learning the Photoshop tool through the free online service and am ready to step up to the next plane. Metal prints of a foliage scene and a garden scene arrived today... [insert large smile here]. Thanks again. I am glad I discovered this site; it's obvious I can learn a lot right here.

This solves the problem!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7vSJ6iNkZH4

In response to Msgr. Jouet -

Well I am hardly an expert. Just someone who tripped upon something that worked and decided to share it. I am really glad that it helped. I have no problems now downloading photos from my new Canon camera (circa 2013); so it seems that Canon and Apple are playing nice with each other again with the newer cameras. Still it is nice to know that Canon built in a fail safe in the older cameras to allow PTP communications no matter what. As far as photo editing (and painting) software goes, the sky really is the limit. It really is a matter of personal preference and style.

Really glad it does Mary! Good luck!

Anna

Thanks very much Mary and Anna. I've been doing a lot of research to confirm my camera choice, looking into photo apps for OS-X, learning more about photo editing, programs for that function, online photo storage, and web page development, photo marketing strategies, and more. I am getting way ahead of myself, but the tax refund came so very soon I will be buying an EOS Rebel T5i EF-S 18-55mm IS STM Kit. In time, I get get another lens, but this will keep my hands full with learning and shooting.

In response to Msgr. Jouet - Sounds like great fun. Let me know how you like your new camera!

Thank you so much! I had taken hundreds of pictures of a musical performance and was faced with the exact same issue - your solution worked perfectly and really saved me huge trouble. Cannot express how much I appreciate this advice!

In response to Kathryn:

Really glad it helped Kathryn. That was why I wrote the article. Thanks for letting me know.

Anna



I was really pleased to have found your article, as I had almost given up in my search to find how to get my pictures into Photos on my iMac i7, using El Capitan. I have an old Canon Powershot A620 [still great by the way] and it was Esko Herrala's solution 17 months ago that solved the problem. The camera does not have Communications/PTP but it does have "Print order/Set up/Print type/Index and it was setting the camera to "Index" that worked. I did nothing more. When I opened Photos the camera appeared and all was well. I hope this may help others struggling with El Capitan! Thanks for taking the trouble to write it up.

Thanks for posting the additional fix for Canon cameras without the Communications/PTP setting Robert.

Mac OS X El Capitan 10.11.5 imports photos from my new Canon EOS Rebel SL1 directly to Photos from the camera without issue. It is just my very old Canon EOS Digital Rebel (the original) that requires the setting adjustment.

I meant to respond to an earlier comment by someone having difficulties. By now my new Canon is unpacked and tried out, the software loaded (Anna's right, the imports go right into Apple's new Photo tool), and I am busy having fun. I've gone about it gingerly to make sure my learning sticks onto my glial cells but have made giant steps. When you are the one in the family with some photographic skill, you get put in charge of standard family album passage-of-time shots which is a good time to learn, and this past week filled with graduations gave me a chance. Someone else commented that Apple's Photo insists on organizing as per their scheme but this is not true. I am just learning but the first discovery was that that shot you just imported should be considered the original and the first step you should take is to set up a separate filing scheme on your iMac and then create one or more copies of that original. You will always have the original, but you can make copies with which to use the new built-in tool with which you can adjust light, color, sharpness, etc. as well as crop and enhance and more. When you are finished, you can use the built-in export tool to take it out to social media, a storage cloud or other site, or simply to your desktop and then into your own files. Apple's Photo also allows naming within it, and records the photographic metadata right off the Canon, and you can add geographic data if you'd like. Frankly, it's the nuts. Thanks, Anna, for the platform. the answers and some inspiration. P.S.: Am packing to move into a new house so will change e-mails in July. A lovely place with a small backyard garden, so "instant" setting/topix.

Thank you. I have a Canon EOS 10D and the manual did not even show a reference to Communication or PTP when doing a search. Many thanks for getting out the word.

I have been struggling with this issue for a year now since I got my new Yosemite MAC. I have a Canon 7D and a Fuji X100S and have never had this problem before. It has been driving me crazy. I am also struggling with ICloud which seems to think that it can extort me to spend money saving photos on my MAC or it will delete them forever. That is another issue, but I must say, the amount of time I have spent trying to second guess and find usable things like Epson Printers, computers and cameras, cameras in general, is ridiculous.

In response to Sharon:

Hi Sharon. Unless your Canon 7D is quite old, the newer Canon cameras have no problem exporting photos directly to Photos on an iMac running Yosemite or El Capitan. If you have not done so already, I would suggest that you go to the Canon Support website and check under Drivers and Downloads for your model Canon to make sure that you have the latest Canon firmware on the camera, and the latest version of the Canon EOS Utility for your model camera and for the version of Yosemite that you are running on your Mac. If you do and the photos still will not import, then changing the communications setting on the camera will solve that problem.

With regard to iCloud: The charge is minimal for iCloud Photo Library if you need/want to use it to share your photos. Alternatively, you do not have to enable iCloud Photo Library in Photos, and you can still import images from your camera to the Photos app on your Mac without having iCloud involved if that is what you want. If you have already enabled iCloud Photo Library, you can call Apple support and they will take you through the steps to turn it off without losing your images. You have to be certain that you have checked the box that says "Download original images to my Mac" first, and give the service time to do that, before turning iCloud Photo Library off, so that the full size original images will reside in your Photos library on the hard drive on your Mac, not just in iCloud.

With regard to peripherals: I have never had a problem with connectivity or compatibility of my Macs with any Epson or HP printers since I bought my first Mac in 2007. Epson printers are pretty testy on their own, but they do work. We have an Epson Workforce 7610 connected wirelessly to my mid-2011 iMac and to my husband's mid-2007 iMac, both running the latest version of Mac OS X El Capitan 10.11.5. I also have an old Epson SPR1800 that worked fine with both iMacs until the printer died. We have also had 2 or 3 different model Epson and HP printers over the years and all have worked fine with every version of the Mac OS X operating system since OS X Snow Leopard. So I suspect that whatever printer issues you are having are related to the software that you are using to send images to the printer, or with a printer or software setting.

I hear you though about printing being a pain. In my humble opinion, the photo editing/photo management software companies and/or the printer manufacturers all need to do a better job documenting software/printer settings when it comes to printing. If you are using Adobe Lightroom or Photoshop to print photos from your Mac, there are many good books explaining how to use those software packages. I would recommend browsing through Amazon, or trying the Adobe online help community on Adobe's website for assistance/information.

All the best,
Anna Porter

Thank you, thank you, thank you!

Not sure what I would have done if I hadn't found your blog. Thanks so much!!!!

In response to Connie -

You are most welcome Connie! Really glad it helped!

Anna Porter
[email protected]

In response to Cassandra -

You are most welcome Cassandra. Thanks so much for the feedback!

Anna Porter
[email protected]

I don't think I LOVE YOU fully expresses my feelings! Even in all caps! I thought my camera cord must have gone bad. I am so glad I found your post. Worked like a charm! I had already wasted an hour looking for another cord to try it out. You saved me a huge headache!!

In response to Lorie :

Glad to be of help. Thanks for the great feedback!

Anna Porter

Wow. I totally love you for this. Of course, Apple could not help me AT ALL. Thank you! They always want me to use their program (iPhoto or Photos now), but they actually keep your images from you. You can't actually access the original files. It's bizarre. It's like they want to steal your content. I know it sounds paranoid, but it's so odd.

Thanks So Very Much!
Laura

In response to Laura Vena -

I am happy the information was helpful Laura. When I import photos from my Canon to my Mac, I always put them in a folder on an external hard drive first. You can do this with Image Capture on your Mac, if you do not have the Canon EOS Utility from Canon, or if it is not working properly on your version of Mac OS X. As I mentioned in an earlier post, my newer Canon EOS Rebel SL1 came with a newer version of EOS Utility 2, and that runs fine on Mac OS X El Capitan 10.11.6, which is what I am currently running on my Mac. Then I either pull that entire folder from the external hard drive into my Photos library (if I like all the images), or I select the images that I like and pull only those photos into my Photos library. This gives me a copy of the original images in Canon RAW format on my external hard drive, as well as a copy on my Mac in my Photos library.

However, you can always access the original version of an image in your Photos library, even after you have made changes to it. There is a feature in Photos to "Revert to Original". And when you export an image from Photos, there is an option to "Export Original" (without any edits), or you can "Export Current" (with edits), as well as options to export the image in a variety of file types. So Apple is not trying to keep your images away from you. It does keep those images in a database (your Photos library), but it keeps the original image safe and you always have access to it.

Also when you set up your Photos library initially, you have the option of setting it up so that original images are stored in the Photos Library, or it can be set up so that original images are kept outside of Photos, which is a "referenced library". If you read through the Photos Help function on your Mac, it explains how to do this.

I prefer to bring the original images into my Photos Library for easy editing and sharing on all of my Apple devices (Mac, iPhone5 and iPad Air 2) via iCloud Photos and iCloud Photo Sharing, pkus keep an additional copy of the original image in Canon RAW firmat on an external hard drive, because it provides me with a backup of that original image there, and I can quickly and easily import those images from the external hard drive into Adobe Lightroom or Adobe Photoshop, if I want to work with the original images in those applications, without having to first export them from Photos.

I hope this information helps.

Anna Porter

YOU JUST SAVED MY LIFE!! Thanks for this and the PTP totally worked! Take care and So appreciate the info!

To Stacy:

I am glad it was helpful Stacy! Thanks so much for the feedback!

Thanks for this simple solution. I haven't used my 20d for a few years and just discovered that I couldn't move images to my computer, then found this solution. Now I can do a photo shoot tomorrow of my granddaughter to capture some high school memories for her
.

In response to John:

Thrilled that this will help you capture memories of your daughter! Those years go by so very fast!

All the best,

Anna Porter

This did it. Thank you SO much for your help! I would never in a million years have figured this out on my own.

In response to Anne:

I am glad you found my post and that it helped. Enjoy your Canon camera and your Mac.

Anna Porter

THANK YOU!!!!! I was Googling all over the place and stumbled on your page and really appreciate it. I found the setting, switched the communication and WAAA-LAAAA. Pictures!! Being a mom of 4 growing kids, full-time nurse, entrepreneur, and taking up photography on the side—this was incredibly helpful.

In response to Raizel:

Really happy this was helpful. Thank you Kindly for letting me know and good luck with your photography!

Anna Porter

Many thanks :-) I spent a few hours downloading lots of drivers and utilities without success... then I stumbled on your blogpost :-)

Greetings from Belgium !

In response to Jean-Paul in Belgium -

So glad this post was helpful. Enjoy your camera!

Anna Porter

Having spent hours today in communication with Apple Chat and the Apple Store I was at a loss as to why
my new AppleMac would not recognise my device. Tried loads of things and then read your advice.
Fantastic - changed communication settings and bingo! You are a star - Many thanks x

In response to Mimi -

Really happy that you found my post and that this little trick is still helping people get their Canon cameras to talk to their Apple iMacs. Enjoy your new Mac and your camera!

Anna Porter

thank you so much! saved my sunny Saturday afternoon :)

In response to ana:

You are most welcome ana. I am glad the information was helpful.

Anna Porter

Holy Christ!!! That is amazing!! Thank you. Took me two seconds to do.

Thank you for sharing this info - as the many comments show, this is a life-saver for so many people. One thing I would like to add - after changing this setting on my EOS350d it appeared in the Photos app but with "No Photos" in the right pane (also tried the Image Capture app but it also showed nothing). So I was almost giving up and already checking online shops to buy a USB CF-card reader when a minute or 2 later the photos actually started appearing. Maybe it took a while because I still had 350 old photos on there. Patience is a virtue I guess :)
Thanks again! (On a snowy Sunday afternoon in Belgium - they're rare here :))

In response to Herbert:

Thanks for adding that tip Herbert. Yes if you have a lot of images and perhaps a slower connection it could take awhile to populate the images. I have seen this before. Seems like it was especially delayed in your case but I am just glad it worked for you.

I had no idea when I first did this blog post how useful it would be for so many people. Especially after all this time. I am really glad that I shared it. And thankful that people like you are kind enough to take the time to comment.

Anna Porter

You are my personal hero! I still spent half a day searching until I found this post, but after that everything worked perfectly and I can finally use my EOS 10D again!

In response to Joe --

Glad it helped and that you can enjoy your Canon EOS 10D once more!

A thousand thank-yous for the PTP information!!!!!
I would NEVER have figured this out alone.


Leave a Comment

* required

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post